The Baystate Objectivist

The Baystate Objectivist

Thursday, April 28, 2011

Ben Stein at UMass

When promoting your event at UMass, it pays to do so with a smile.

However, the UMass Republican Club preferred to promote their guest speaker event with a rather serious looking display at the Campus Center.

However it seemed to work, as last night they got the largest turnout I've ever seen at a UMass GOP sponsored event.

Maybe the reason for the full house was that the speaker wasn't some dreary conservative politician but the TV and movie celebrity Ben Stein, probably best known for his role in the movie Ferris Bueller's Day Off. Recently his performance in that film was voted by some magazine as one of the 50 funniest scenes in the history of American Cinema.

But Stein is much more than just an actor and comedian. He is a passionate, if somewhat eccentric right-wing activist and a financial expert whose prognostications on economics are respected on Wall Street. He is also a prominent critic of the United States educational system. For reasons that were not explained, Stein demanded that his talk last night not be recorded, but here's his opening remarks which I captured before all cameras were ordered turned off. Normally I would have considered such a command a mere dare, but I wasn't in my kamikaze free speech mode last night and besides I wanted to hear the speech and so I didn't want to get thrown out. In any case, note Stein's praise of the UMass dining services food, a real compliment when you consider how Stein has appeared (and been treated to free dinners) at every major college in the country.

Conspicuous in their absence last night was the presence of rabble-rousing leftists, who in past years have actually driven conservative speakers right off the stage with their antics, sometimes resulting in national negative publicity for UMass. This incident I filmed at a talk by anti-feminist professor Mike Adams in 2006 has become a YouTube classic of campus intolerance.

Despite the Republican sponsorship of the talk, not everything Stein said would please most conservatives. Although he complained that the spending curve has "gone vertical" under Obama, he was critical of the free-spending Bush Administration as well. Stein insisted that tax increases, preferably on the rich, "are inevitable" if the national debt is to be brought under control. He described his next door neighbors Nick Nolte and Barbara Streisand as having three Bentleys in their garage, and said he favored tax increases that would make them downscale to Cadillacs. However he also said that liberals would have to face the reality that "Social Security and Medicare as we have traditionally known them are absolutely dead."

He also launched into a scathing condemnation of American education, although he impishly assured the audience that he wasn't referring to "any schools anywhere around here." His examples of modern educational stupidity were often very funny, but he was dead serious when he declared that America "cannot be a first rate nation with an uneducated, unskilled, third rate work force."

While angry leftists were nowhere to be heard, in the question and answer portion of his talk he faced harsh criticism from an unlikely source - angry biology majors! Stein gained some notoriety a few years ago by stating that he thought the evidence in favor of evolution was more inconclusive than most scientists will admit. That resulted in some hostile questions last night from students in the biological sciences. He was surprisingly thin-skinned about this criticism, with the Jewish Stein at one point declaring "The last time scientists confronted my people they were directing them to a gas chamber." This comparison of scientists to Nazis resulted in the only smattering of booing all evening.

Yet Stein's appearance overall was a big success, avoiding any of the ugly incidents that have marred UMass Republican events in the past, and in all Stein came across as a brilliant, good humored man with provocative views who provided worthwhile food for thought whatever your ideology.

Elsewhere on campus, you can tell that Spring has truly arrived when you see poetry classes being conducted on the lawn outside Bartlett Hall.

Parents visiting the campus recently were invited to take rides on a horse and buggy. For what they pay to send their kids to UMass, they should have been given rides in a golden chariot!

Lycanthropy at the bus stop.

I'm sorry to see these ancient trees being cut down. These are the trees that remember the farm people who once dominated Amherst but who have long vanished.

The Mullens Center from the 24th floor of the UMass library.


Ed said...

Read the banner on the table -- the UMass Republican Club now exists in name only -- that is a chapter of College Republicans. Note the age and attire of the audience, those aren't UMass students either.

When Ben Stien last spoke at UMass, we filled the room and had it broadcast live on the dorm cable system. Funny how he didn't allow that this time, isn't it....

Anonymous said...

I saw Ben Stein's "No Intelligence Allowed". Interesting. I can imagine it would get under some biology majors's skin.

But the one about science directing Jews into the gas chambers was really a cheap shot. Really cheap. That's about as cheap as the other side that likes to suggest that religion was responsible for the Holocaust. So stupid.